qi-hardware/gmenu2x
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of git://projects.qi-hardware.com/gmenu2x.git synced 2024-11-22 07:29:44 +02:00
Code

Removed screenshot caching from Selector

Browse Source 
The way the caching was implemented was rather problematic. Also I'm
not convinced caching is useful at all. So I removed it. If at some
point we decide that caching is a good idea, it would be best to
re-implement it from scratch, so nothing of value is lost by removing
the existing caching code.

One problem was that the prepare method would check the existence of
a screenshot file for every file in the directory, which adds to the
noticable delay before showing a directory which holds many files.

Another problem is there was no upper limit to the number of
screenshots that would be cached. On directories with many screenshots
the memory use could rise to several hundred megabytes, which can be
problematic on some of the systems we want to support.

Also there was a rather nasty hack present to ensure screenshots were
loaded without an alpha channel.

My main doubt about the usefulness of screenshot caching is that
caching will only speed up the showing of an image from the second
time onwards. In typical use, the average screenshot is displayed at
most once. If the image load time is long enough to annoy the user,
any real solution would have to work also for the first showing.
For example, background (asynchronous) loading could be implemented.
This commit is contained in:
Maarten ter Huurne 2014-08-12 08:06:15 +02:00
parent 3305cf289b
commit 1229ef32e5
2 changed files with 17 additions and 37 deletions
Show Stats Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

48
src/selector.cpp
View File

@ -85,13 +85,13 @@ int Selector::exec(int startSelection) {
unsigned int firstElement = 0;
unsigned int selected = constrain(startSelection, 0, fl.size() - 1);
vector<string> screens, titles;
prepare(&fl,&screens,&titles);
vector<string> titles;
prepare(&fl,&titles);
//Add the folder icon manually to be sure to load it with alpha support since we are going to disable it for screenshots
if (gmenu2x->sc.skinRes("imgs/folder.png")==NULL)
gmenu2x->sc.addSkinRes("imgs/folder.png");
gmenu2x->sc.defaultAlpha = false;
auto folderIcon = gmenu2x->sc.skinRes("imgs/folder.png");
if (!folderIcon) {
folderIcon = gmenu2x->sc.addSkinRes("imgs/folder.png");
}
bool close = false, result = true;
while (!close) {
@ -105,9 +105,10 @@ int Selector::exec(int startSelection) {
firstElement = selected;
//Screenshot
if (selected-fl.dirCount()<screens.size()
&& !screens[selected-fl.dirCount()].empty()) {
Surface *screenshot = gmenu2x->sc[screens[selected-fl.dirCount()]];
if (fl.isFile(selected)) {
string& noext = titles[selected - fl.dirCount()];
string path = screendir + noext + ".png";
auto screenshot = OffscreenSurface::loadImage(path, "", false);
if (screenshot) {
screenshot->blitRight(s, 320, 0, 320, 240, 128u);
}
@ -124,7 +125,7 @@ int Selector::exec(int startSelection) {
&& i < firstElement + nb_elements; i++) {
iY = i-firstElement;
if (fl.isDirectory(i)) {
gmenu2x->sc["imgs/folder.png"]->blit(s, 4, top + (iY * fontheight));
folderIcon->blit(s, 4, top + (iY * fontheight));
gmenu2x->font->write(s, fl[i], 21,
top + (iY * fontheight) + (fontheight / 2),
Font::HAlignLeft, Font::VAlignMiddle);
@ -185,7 +186,7 @@ int Selector::exec(int startSelection) {
dir = dir.substr(0,p+1);
selected = 0;
firstElement = 0;
prepare(&fl,&screens,&titles);
prepare(&fl,&titles);
}
}
break;
@ -202,7 +203,7 @@ int Selector::exec(int startSelection) {
selected = 0;
firstElement = 0;
prepare(&fl,&screens,&titles);
prepare(&fl,&titles);
}
break;
@ -211,19 +212,14 @@ int Selector::exec(int startSelection) {
}
}
gmenu2x->sc.defaultAlpha = true;
freeScreenshots(&screens);
return result ? (int)selected : -1;
}
void Selector::prepare(FileLister *fl, vector<string> *screens, vector<string> *titles) {
void Selector::prepare(FileLister *fl, vector<string> *titles) {
fl->setPath(dir);
freeScreenshots(screens);
screens->resize(fl->getFiles().size());
titles->resize(fl->getFiles().size());
string screendir = dir;
screendir = dir;
if (!screendir.empty() && screendir[screendir.length() - 1] != '/') {
screendir += "/";
}
@ -237,19 +233,5 @@ void Selector::prepare(FileLister *fl, vector<string> *screens, vector<string> *
if (pos!=string::npos && pos>0)
noext = noext.substr(0, pos);
titles->at(i) = noext;
DEBUG("Searching for screen '%s%s.png'\n", screendir.c_str(), noext.c_str());
if (fileExists(screendir+noext+".png"))
screens->at(i) = screendir+noext+".png";
else
screens->at(i) = "";
}
}
void Selector::freeScreenshots(vector<string> *screens) {
for (uint i=0; i<screens->size(); i++) {
if (!screens->at(i).empty())
gmenu2x->sc.del(screens->at(i));
}
}

6
src/selector.h
View File

@ -34,11 +34,9 @@ class Selector : protected Dialog {
private:
int selRow;
LinkApp *link;
std::string file, dir;
std::string file, dir, screendir;
void prepare(FileLister *fl, std::vector<std::string> *screens,
std::vector<std::string> *titles);
void freeScreenshots(std::vector<std::string> *screens);
void prepare(FileLister *fl, std::vector<std::string> *titles);
public:
Selector(GMenu2X *gmenu2x, LinkApp *link,