The tablet was opt-in (VT1200_TABLET=1) with the mouse as the default. Invert
it: the tablet is selected with no environment, and VT1200_MOUSE=1 (a
value-aware inverse switch, so VT1200_MOUSE=0 selects the tablet) restores the
VSXXX-AA mouse.
The real terminal almost certainly has a mouse, so this is a DELIBERATE
divergence from the target machine, documented in README.md alongside
VT1200_SKIP_LEVEL1 and VT1200_IO_PATH_STUB. It is on by default because the OS
is only reachable through the skip gate and there the tablet's absolute reports
are what make the Terminal Manager usable.
Baselines re-measured, both unchanged:
* no-env progress.lua at 200 frames: PC=3FDCE400 samples=198 (3 PCs) -> same.
DUART2-B is never addressed in that window (the T/R exchange is OS-phase
only), so the reply bytes A0 04 00 00 vs A0 02 00 00 and the 5- vs 3-byte
framing do not reach the CPU.
* VT1200_SKIP_LEVEL1=1 frame 3000: pixel-identical for tablet and
VT1200_MOUSE=1 (magick AE=0); both reproduce the committed
tablet_cursor_*.png frames exactly.
VT1200_TABLET is now a no-op; run.sh's tablet mode is reported to the owner for
rewording (its comments are his).
The terminal tells the two pointing devices apart from the 'T' self-test
device code (0010 mouse / 0100 tablet) and switches report framing on it:
3-byte relative for the mouse, 5-byte absolute (header 110) for the tablet.
Verified against the running OS: with the tablet it reads the self-test as
A0 04 00 00 and then reads RHRB in groups of 5 (groups of 3 for the mouse).
Refactor the VSXXX model into a shared base + mouse/tablet subclasses and
select the device on DUART2-B with VT1200_TABLET=1 (default: the mouse, so
the mouse stays and is selectable, not replaced). The tablet reports its
documented 0..2199 active area (VCB02 D.1) and reads the host pointer
through IPT_LIGHTGUN_X/Y, MAME's absolute control, so the emulated cursor
follows the host pointer positionally: corner (0,0) -> (194,38), centre
(1100,1100) -> (704,467), corner (2199,2199) -> (1214,898), reproducible
pixel-for-pixel on a repeated coordinate. Driving it from the host mouse
needs '-lightgun -lightgun_device mouse' (documented for run.sh; run.sh is
not edited here).
The mouse and keyboard are unchanged, and all baselines hold: no env
PC=3FDCE400 samples=198 (3 PCs); VT1200_IO_PATH_STUB=1 samples=53 (75 PCs);
ROM md5 unchanged. Nothing is tuned to satisfy level 0's I/O data path test.
Add the terminal's actual input parts to the harness as device models on the
already-modelled SCN2681 at DUART2: a DEC LK401 keyboard (channel A, 4800 8N1)
and a DEC VSXXX-AA mouse (channel B, 4800 8O1), both driven by MAME's host
input and wired bit-by-bit to the DUART (rx_a_w/rx_b_w and a_tx_cb/b_tx_cb).
Route: the docs, not MAME's lk201. MAME's lk201 device executes the 68HC05
firmware 23-001s9-00.bin, which is not in our ROM set (the downloaded zip only
carries the 8051 23-004M2-00.bin, MAME's unused second region), so route 1 is
unusable without sourcing that ROM. The models follow PROTOCOL.md: the keyboard
answers FD with the 4-byte self-test and reports documented keycodes honouring
the division modes; the mouse answers T with its 4-byte self-test and streams
3-byte incremental reports.
One physical-layer detail was required: the SCN2681 receiver mis-samples the
first byte after a receiver reset unless the line is explicitly idle-high
before the start bit. Both models now hold TxD at mark when idle (which is
faithful anyway) -- isolated evidence: bit-banging 0x55 into rx_a_w gives
RHRA=D5 with no idle-high, RHRA=55 with four idle-high bits.
Verified (VT1200_SKIP_LEVEL1=1, input_inject.lua): the OS reads the keyboard
keycode 0xC2 (A) and ~900 bytes of VSXXX reports (dx=+16/+32); after the
self-test it switches the mouse to stream mode; the X11 cursor arrow is visible
at frame 4400 and has moved by frame 4600.
Nothing was tuned for the level-0 I/O data-path test: with no env the boot
still fails it honestly and the regression baseline is unchanged
(PC=3FDCE400 samples=198, 3 PCs). VT1200_IO_PATH_STUB=1 (53/75) and the skip
run (Terminal Manager at frame 3000) are also unchanged. ROM md5 unchanged.
See harness/mame/INPUT_REPORT.md.
The level-0 I/O data path test writes one 0xE1 byte to DUART2-A THRA and
demands exactly 10 bytes back; it checks only the count and never compares
the content, and no documented keyboard/mouse/tablet message is 10 bytes.
Add an opt-in stand-in that watches for that 0xE1 write and feeds 10
arbitrary (0x00) bytes on the channel's receive path via the SCN2681's
public rx_fifo_push(), refilling the 4-deep FIFO on each RHRA read.
This is explicitly NOT a keyboard model: it stands in for an unknown test
fixture on the keyboard port. It replies only while the channel is polled
(IMR=0x00), so it raises no interrupt; with the stub on the run clears
level 0 and reaches level 1's HOST PORT - 15, but still no OS (SKIP_LEVEL1
remains the only route to X11). Default is unchanged: no env still fails
level 0 honestly (progress.lua samples=198/3 PCs); stub-on is 53/75 PCs.
See harness/mame/README.md.
The real VT1200 board has a DUART2 (SCN2681) at 0x0620000 for the keyboard
(ch A) and mouse (ch B) with INT2 wired. Map it unconditionally instead of
opting in via VT1200_DUART2; the OS's DUART interrupt dispatcher needs a real
read-only ISR distinct from the write-only IMR.
Verified with frame dumps: with ONLY VT1200_SKIP_LEVEL1=1 the Terminal Manager
V2.2 dialog now appears (frame 3000; VRAM md5 73c3c9a1..., identical to the old
skip+DUART2 run).
This does NOT keep the faithful no-env path: level 0's I/O data path test
(L3FDCE470) transmits 0xE1 to DUART2-A and drains the receiver until it has read
10 bytes (SRA RxRDY). The board write-back latch used to alias CSRA/RHRA and
faked that (baseline first divergence: R 06200001 pc=3FDCE670 = 0x0099 vs the
real chip's 0x000C), so the firmware dropped into the interactive diagnostics
menu. No faithful device we have (LK401 sends at most 4 bytes) supplies the 10
bytes; an external TX->RX loopback does not change the transmit count. See
OS_BRINGUP_REPORT.md section 8 (DONE_WITH_CONCERNS).
The OS keyboard/mouse driver does initialise: skip-phase OS code programs
DUART2 (MR1A=0x13, CSRA=0x99, IMR=0x33, ...) and sends FD to the keyboard plus
the documented LED/click/bell/auto-repeat commands, and 'T' to the mouse.
The skip gate reaches the root weave and stops: video RAM and the rendered
frame are byte-identical at frames 3000/10000/30000/45000/60000 (42 s -> 14
min), and all 4 MiB of main RAM is identical at every sample except one byte
that oscillates. The PC histogram is tight: entered at frame ~611, dominated
by 0x3FB30390/0x3FB30110.
Wall: DUART2 (0x0620000, keyboard/mouse) is unmodelled, so the read-only ISR
at 0x06200005 is served by the board write-back latch and returns the value
the OS wrote to the write-only IMR (0x0033). The OS's DUART dispatcher
(0x3FB43800) masks 0x66 -> 0x22, so it services a phantom interrupt that can
never clear, spinning in the channel handler 0x3FB42410 and queue routine
0x3FB300F0. Forcing only 0x06200005 to 0 reproduces the full DUART2-mapped
run byte-for-byte; with VT1200_DUART2=1 the Terminal Manager dialog box from
the reference video appears at frame 3000 and the machine runs on.
Defaults unchanged: no-env still reaches HOST PORT - 15, skip still reaches
the weave. New opt-in knobs VT1200_DUMP_{FRAME,RAM_FRAMES,VRAM_FRAMES} and
resolve_console.py; progress.lua untouched.
A bare 'vt1200 vt1200' now boots exactly as the old six-variable incantation
(VRAM, handshake busy=2, DUART1, monitor switch) did, so the no-env run is no
longer a silently-broken machine.
Promoted (5): VT1200_VRAM, VT1200_BOARD_MODEL, VT1200_BOARD_BUSY_TICKS,
VT1200_DUART, VT1200_DUART_SEL (folded to DUART1-only; DUART2 is the new
opt-in VT1200_DUART2).
Deleted (15): VT1200_CAL/_VID4M/_W8, VT1200_BOARD_RAM/_DEFAULT/_BUSY_W2/
_BUSY_W3/_DMA_TICKS/_SWITCH, VT1200_DUART_LB1/LB2, VT1200_LOWLOG,
VT1200_VRAMLOG, VT1200_STRUCTLOG, VT1200_DUART1_INT2.
VT1200_BOARD_SWITCH is superseded: 0x0640000D is the DUART1 IP register, and
the DUART mapping wins the last-wins slice, so the board model switch was
never consulted (verified: identical output with and without it).
Renamed: VT1200_DUART_IP3 -> VT1200_SKIP_LEVEL1, which now also selects the
OS-phase DUART1 IRQ routing (INT2) instead of POST's INT1, removing the
standalone VT1200_DUART1_INT2 knob. The skip gate itself stays opt-in.
Evidence (equivalence): frame-160/200/600 md5, progress.lua at 200/1500
frames, and the cap.lua console transcript from the no-env run are
byte-identical to the incantation run. Re-baseline: no-env 200-frame hottest
PC 3FDCE400 samples 199 (1 PC) -> samples 53 (78 PCs). ROM md5 unchanged
b46a3e442ccb86134d2356bd70d22fd2. Header comment block updated; see
harness/mame/GATE_CLEANUP_REPORT.md.
vt1200.cpp declared PALETTE(config, m_palette).set_entries(256) with no init
delegate, so render_active_line()'s pens 0/1 rendered in whatever MAME's
default palette held -- reported as red on screen. Use
palette_device::MONOCHROME (emupal.cpp: palette_init_monochrome) with two
entries, so the colour is ours and deterministic.
Verified via a real MAME screenshot (screen:snapshot(), which renders through
the palette -- dump_frame()'s PPM is straight from bitmap pens and cannot show
colour): pal_mono_frame600.png is exactly black (0,0,0) + white (255,255,255).
palverify.lua takes the screenshot; the frame is the level-1 error screen.
The OS's DUART1 driver services the 0x6400000 window from the INT2 stub
(0x0F30 -> 0x3FA93070); with the default INT1 wiring the DUART1 TxRDY IRQ is
handed to the INT1 stub's 0x5800000 board-DMA handler (0x3F7151F0 ->
0x3F9D5B40), which never reads the DUART ISR, so INTPEND's INT1 bit stays
latched and the CPU re-enters the handler ~387x per frame.
Empirical A/B (level-1-skipped boot via VT1200_DUART_IP3):
default (INT1): INT1 stub entered 387x in one frame; screen frozen.
VT1200_DUART1_INT2=1: zero interrupt entries in a one-frame trace;
the OS reads DUART1 ISR (reg5) at pc=3FB43900 right after the IRQ.
INTENB reads 0x0606 (INT1|INT2|HI|DI), so the routing (not the enable mask)
is what identifies the line. Opt-in; default unchanged.
osprobe.lua: also print INTENB and DUART1 MR1A/CSRA in the globals dump.
Add an opt-in knob (VT1200_DUART_IP3=1) that asserts DUART1 input-port bit 3.
The POST gate at bit 0x3F2042D0 tests IP3 (@0x64000D0 bit 3) and, when it is
high and the 0x6200000 status handshake did not return 0x55, branches to the
OS cold-start 0x3F5788C0 (jauc), skipping the whole level-1 batch: the sole
caller of the level-1 runner 0x3FDF72D0 is 0x3F204400, inside the skipped
region. Verified from the raw opcodes against MAME's tms34010 opcode table
(BTST_K sets Z=NOT bit; jane=JNE absolute-long) and empirically.
Default behaviour is unchanged (no env -> the gate is not taken). The real
terminal reads IP3 low, so this is a modelled board input, not a faithful POST
path; results from a level-1-skipped harness are not evidence about the real
hardware's POST, but are evidence about the OS/graphics route.
osprobe.lua: gate/OS/Park probe (breakpoints on 0x3F2043B0 / 0x3F204400 /
0x3F5788C0, per-frame PC histogram, optional instruction trace and RAM-global
dump).
MAME's TMS34010 renderer does not read VRAM: tms340x0_ind16 calls the
driver's scanline callback for the active region and paints only the
blanking regions. Our callback drew nothing, so the active area was
never painted and every frame dump was all-black.
Add render_active_line(), called from scanline(): it reads the
framebuffer out of the video-RAM share at bit 0x04000000 with a measured
1024-bit (0x40-word, 128-byte) row pitch and LSB-first bit order within
each 16-bit word. The pitch comes from the firmware's own character
blitter (PIXBLT at pc=3FDF9A00 advances its destination by 0x40 words per
glyph row); at the 160-byte pitch MAME derived from HEBLNK/HSBLNK/HTOTAL
the text is sheared and unreadable.
Validated: frame 160 shows the level-1 CP437 character table legibly,
frame 600 the level-1 error screen. VT1200_DPYLOG added as an opt-in
per-scanline display-params dump.
Regression (no VT1200_* env): PC=3FDCE400 samples=199 -- holds.
See harness/mame/RENDER_REPORT.md.
Root cause of the missing THRA write (HOST PORT test): the level-1 host-port
test's transmit is ISR-driven, and the DUART interrupt was never wired to the
CPU. The firmware installs RAM trampolines in the fixed vector table (INT1
vector 0xffffffc0 -> stub at bit 0x0f60 = JA 0x3FA92F40, which calls the DUART
ISR L3FA78D90 with (2, 0x270860, 0x6400000)). Counters: INTENB reaches 0x0006
(INT1|INT2) at the test, so interrupts are enabled.
vt1200.cpp: wire m_duart1/m_duart2 irq_cb() to CPU external interrupt 1/2
(duart1_irq_w/duart2_irq_w), gated on VT1200_DUART. Result: THRA writes go
from 0 to 20 per run; the test's SRA-overrun and RHRA-pattern checks now pass.
MAME tree (mc68681.cpp/.h), two datasheet-backed corrections with revert notes:
1. TxRDY was asserted mid-character ("not until the end of start bit time");
the datasheet asserts it at the THR->TSR transfer. Corrected.
2. The overrun error was latched when the overrunning character *completed*
(rx_fifo_push); the datasheet latches it "upon receipt of the start bit of
the new (overrunning) character". Corrected via duart_channel::rx_w().
This clears every check in the RXCHECK sub-test (flags 1 -> 0).
Acceptance is NOT met: cap.lua still prints 'LEVEL1/2 ERROR -> HOST PORT - 15'.
The next failure is the preceding L3FA71BC0 (DUART baud/timer) sub-test
returning 6; its flag-set sites were breakpointed and never fired. Regression
holds (no VT1200_* env -> PC=3FDCE400 samples=199). Details, numbers and the
datasheet audit: harness/mame/DUART_REPORT.md sections FINAL FINDINGS / UPDATE.
Adds SCN2681 devices at 0x0640000 (DUART1 = host/printer) and 0x0620000
(DUART2 = keyboard/mouse), gated on VT1200_DUART, with the remap
verified as duart_register = handler_off (duart_byte = off*2, value in
the low byte of the firmware's 16-bit move). Optional external TX->RX
loopback (VT1200_DUART_LB1/2) models the loopback connectors; the
monitor switch is driven on IP4-IP6. New VT1200_DUARTLOG gives a full
non-deduplicated DUART access log.
Result: the level-1 HOST PORT test is reached and executed against the
real DUART, but still reports 'LEVEL1/2 ERROR -> HOST PORT - 15'. The
test reads SRA/RHRA and requires a 5-byte external pattern
(0xAA,0xFF,0xAA,0x55) plus SRA overrun, yet the firmware never writes
the transmit register (0 writes to reg 3/B on either DUART in 1400
frames), so no internal or external loopback can supply it. See
harness/mame/DUART_REPORT.md.
Regression holds: no VT1200_* env -> PC=3FDCE400 samples=199.
The dispatch status is 0x100 (printed as '22' in the message). A driver-side
transparent low-RAM write log (VT1200_LOWLOG) shows the slot at bit 0x16F0 is
written by the store at 3FDF9090 from a13(0x10), which L3FA7C050 sets to the
literal 0x100 when the memory test L3F2018B0 returns non-zero. L3F2018B0 is the
level-1 video-memory test (base bit 0x04000000, count 0x20000). Its failing
checks: the 16-bit walking-bit read-back at 0x04000000 (baseline, unmapped) and,
with video RAM mapped, the REFCNT (0xC00001F0) 'must change' check.
Closed cross-check (single run): the catch-all and VT1200_CAL proxies are
directly comparable (both base 0) and resolve identically; last-wins holds
for same- and mismatched-width overlaps. The apparent conflict was a units
error: a .rw(FUNC(offs_t)) handler receives (bitaddr-base)>>4 (tms34010
Width=1, AddrShift=3), so the catch-all logs bitaddr>>4. Its 0x400000..0x40D7FF
is bit 0x04000000..0x040D7FF0 (bytes 0x800000..0x81AFFE), outside the declared
4 MiB RAM -- genuinely unmapped. The old 0x00400000 proxy was 16x too low.
Catch-all reproduces the committed log byte-for-byte and does not perturb
coverage (56 / PC=3F208950 with and without). Regression holds: PC=3FDCE400
samples=199. Report: harness/mame/XCROSS_REPORT.md
SDD
arti